Seal
Mendocino Indian Reservation

The National Federation of Mendocino — Lord Devin: Mallonee

Public Notice / Revised Notice of Enactment
Revised Public Notice
National Federation of Mendocino — Office of the Head Chief

Revised Public Notice — CCSAR Protection Act of 2026

Act No.: NFM-2026-CCSAR-003
Notice Reference: NFM-2026-PN-004
Date of Publication: November 18, 2026
Supersedes: All prior public notices concerning guardianship and jurisdiction under this Act

TO ALL PERSONS, AGENCIES, COURTS, LAW ENFORCEMENT BODIES, AND TRIBAL NATIONS TO WHOM THESE PRESENTS MAY COME:

NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Office of the Head Chief enacted the CCSAR Protection Act of 2026 on November 16, 2026. The Act applies neutrally, without regard to religion, ethnicity, or national origin. This Notice supplements the Act and states, in the clearest possible terms, (1) the exclusive jurisdiction of the tribal government over tribal-nation children of the Mendocino Indian Reservation, (2) the final decision-making authority of the established guardian within the tribal process, and (3) the federal-law consequences for any court or agency that invokes a generic “welfare principle” or “best interests” analysis to keep such a child from a guardian who would provide a safe home.

I. Sovereignty and the Controlling Federal Framework

The National Federation of Mendocino is a sovereign tribal government. Its authority over its children is not delegated by any State and is not subject to the supervision of any state court, county agency, municipal body, private institution, or foreign forum. This is not a matter of tribal assertion alone; it is the command of federal law.

§ 1911(a) — Exclusive tribal jurisdiction. The Indian Child Welfare Act provides that “An Indian tribe shall have jurisdiction exclusive as to any State over any child custody proceeding involving an Indian child who resides or is domiciled within the reservation of such tribe,” and that “[w]here an Indian child is a ward of a tribal court, the Indian tribe shall retain exclusive jurisdiction, notwithstanding the residence or domicile of the child”. This jurisdiction is exclusive. It is not concurrent with the State. It is not subject to state-court review on the merits.

§ 1911(d) and § 1914 — Full faith and credit. Every State and every court of the United States “shall give full faith and credit to the public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of any Indian tribe applicable to Indian child custody proceedings to the same extent that such entities give full faith and credit to the public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of any other entity”. A tribal court order is not advisory. It is binding.

California law is in accord. Once a case is transferred to tribal court in California, “the state court loses jurisdiction in the matter.” In re M.M. (2007) 154 Cal.App.4th 897, 912–913. There is no residual state authority to apply a “welfare principle” after that transfer. The state court is without power to act.

II. Guardianship and Final Decision-Making Authority within the Tribal Process

The Office of the Head Chief maintains an official index of established guardianships at nationalfederationofmendocino.org/guardianship.

Where a child is the subject of a CCSAR and a guardian has been established under that index or by the Tribal Court, the guardian identified in the guardianship documents is the person with final decision-making authority in the CCSAR process concerning that child, including decisions about placement, medical care, education, and return of the child.

Where the Head Chief is the established guardian, or is exercising authority under the Constitution of the Mendocino California Tribal Nations, the Head Chief’s determination is the final tribal determination in the CCSAR process concerning that child.

That authority:

  • is exercised under the Constitution of the Mendocino California Tribal Nations;
  • is subject only to the jurisdiction of the Tribal Court under that Constitution;
  • is subject only to the Welfare Principle as applied by the Head Chief and the Tribal Court under tribal law; and
  • is not subject to the judgment, review, supervision, or approval of any non-tribal court, agency, or forum.

This is consistent with §1.04 of the Act (Non-Derogation), which preserves “the rights of any parent or guardian recognised by law,” and with the published guardianship declarations, which appoint the Child Guardian “to act in the Child’s best interests in all matters concerning the Child’s welfare, education, health, maintenance, and property.”

III. No External Court May Use the “Welfare Principle” to Displace Tribal Jurisdiction

The Welfare Principle is a tribal-law standard under this Act. It is applied by the Head Chief and by the Tribal Court. It is not a license held by any other court, agency, institution, or person.

No state court, county court, municipal court, federal court, administrative tribunal, child-welfare agency, private foundation, or foreign forum has authority to invoke the Welfare Principle to override, displace, review, or second-guess the determination of the tribal government concerning a tribal-nation child of the Mendocino Indian Reservation. A tribunal that lacks jurisdiction over the child does not acquire jurisdiction by reciting the words “best interests of the child.”

Any order, finding, recommendation, or report issued by a non-tribal forum purporting to apply the Welfare Principle to such a child is, as against the National Federation of Mendocino and as against the child’s guardian, of no effect. It shall be accorded no comity, no deference, and no recognition by the National Federation of Mendocino, and shall be treated as an intrusion upon tribal sovereignty.

The Welfare Principle is not a mechanism for forum-shopping. A party dissatisfied with a tribal determination may not carry the same question to a non-tribal forum in the hope of a different answer. Where a non-tribal forum is asked to act inconsistently with this Notice, the correct course is to decline jurisdiction and defer to the Tribal Court.

Nothing in this Section limits the Tribal Court’s own authority to apply the Welfare Principle, to issue orders under §§4.02 and 4.03 of the Act, or to review any determination made under the Act.

IV. Definition of “Court of Competent Jurisdiction”

For purposes of this Notice and of the Act as applied to a tribal-nation child of the Mendocino Indian Reservation:

“Court of competent jurisdiction” means the Tribal Court established under the authority of the Mendocino Indian Reservation.

No other court is a “court of competent jurisdiction” for that child unless the Tribal Court has expressly ceded jurisdiction in the particular matter, or binding federal law requires otherwise. Nothing in the Act, and nothing in this Notice, shall be read to confer or imply jurisdiction on any non-tribal court.

V. Federal Non-Compliance Where the Welfare Principle Is Used to Keep a Child from a Safe Guardian

The National Federation of Mendocino states the following as a matter of federal law. A court or agency that invokes a generic “welfare principle” or “best interests” analysis to keep a tribal-nation child from a guardian who would provide a safe home is not acting in a federally compliant manner under the Indian Child Welfare Act.

A. ICWA placement preferences favor the guardian and the child’s extended family. Under 25 U.S.C. § 1915(b), any foster care or preadoptive placement of an Indian child must be with, in order of preference: “(i) a member of the Indian child’s extended family; (ii) a foster home licensed, approved, or specified by the Indian child’s tribe,” and so on. Under § 1915(a), adoptive placements carry the same preference for “a member of the child’s extended family”. These preferences reflect a deliberate federal policy that a child’s own family and tribal community are the preferred placement, not a disfavored one. A guardian established under tribal authority falls within, and is entitled to the benefit of, this statutory hierarchy.

B. A generic “best interests” analysis is not “good cause” to bypass those preferences. The statute permits departure from the placement preferences only “in the absence of good cause to the contrary.” 25 U.S.C. § 1915(a)–(b). Federal authorities confirm that a free-floating “best interests” assessment is not “good cause” to disregard the statutory hierarchy; the best interests of an Indian child are presumed to be served by an ICWA-compliant placement. A court that invokes the “welfare principle” to keep a child from a guardian who would provide a safe home is substituting its own preference for the placement order that Congress mandated.

C. The only federal emergency authority is limited to imminent physical harm, and it ends when that danger ends. The sole provision that allows a State to remove an Indian child from a parent or “Indian custodian” is 25 U.S.C. § 1922, which permits emergency removal “in order to prevent imminent physical damage or harm to the child”. That same section requires that the removal “terminates immediately when such removal or placement is no longer necessary to prevent imminent physical damage or harm to the child,” and that the State “expeditiously initiate a child custody proceeding … transfer the child to the jurisdiction of the appropriate Indian tribe, or restore the child to the parent or Indian custodian”. A court that keeps a child from a safe guardian after any imminent danger has passed is acting beyond the only emergency authority federal law gives it.

D. Improper removal requires the court to return the child. Under 25 U.S.C. § 1920, where a petitioner “has improperly removed the child from custody of the parent or Indian custodian” or “has improperly retained custody after a visit or other temporary relinquishment of custody, the court shall decline jurisdiction over such petition and shall forthwith return the child to his parent or Indian custodian unless returning the child … would subject the child to a substantial and immediate danger or threat of such danger”. Keeping a child from a safe guardian is precisely the circumstance this provision addresses. The standard is “substantial and immediate danger”—not a generalized concern, not a “welfare” preference, and not a disagreement with the guardian’s household.

E. Where the tribal court has jurisdiction, a state court has no power to override its placement determination. For a child who resides or is domiciled on the reservation, or who is a ward of the tribal court, the tribe has jurisdiction “exclusive as to any State.” 25 U.S.C. § 1911(a). In California, once a case is transferred to the tribal court, the state court loses jurisdiction. A state court that purports to apply the “welfare principle” to displace a tribal placement decision is exercising authority it does not have. The “existing Indian family” doctrine—a judicially created exception some courts once used to avoid ICWA—is not viable in California and cannot be invoked to defeat tribal jurisdiction.

Conclusion. A court or agency that (1) invokes the “welfare principle” or “best interests” to (2) keep an Indian child from a guardian who would provide a safe home, and (3) does so without a finding of imminent physical damage or harm and without complying with the § 1915 placement preferences, is not acting in a federally compliant manner under the Indian Child Welfare Act. Such a determination is subject to reversal, and the National Federation of Mendocino will treat it as a violation of federal law and of the child’s right to placement consistent with ICWA.

VI. Primary Goal Where the Child Is Out of the Guardian’s Care

Where a child who is the subject of a CCSAR is not in the physical care of the established guardian, the primary goal of the CCSAR Trigger Protocol is to secure the child’s safety and to return the child to the care of the guardian.

Accordingly:

  • §4.03 (Locate Order Application) shall be understood as seeking the child’s safe location and return to the guardian.
  • §4.02 (Restraining Order Application) shall be framed, where appropriate, to protect the child’s safe reunification with the guardian.
  • §5.03 (Mandatory Consideration of Relief) shall be applied with return to the guardian as the presumptive safe placement.

The child’s physical safety remains the immediate objective. Return to the guardian is the primary placement goal once safety is secured. Any continuation of separation beyond the immediate emergency requires a finding of substantial and immediate danger under § 1920, not a generalized “welfare” preference.

VII. Off-Reservation Children — Transfer and Full Faith and Credit

Where a tribal-nation child of the Mendocino Indian Reservation is not resident or domiciled within the reservation, the tribal government asserts the following, in order of priority:

  • Exclusive jurisdiction, where the child resides or is domiciled within the reservation, or is a ward of the Tribal Court. 25 U.S.C. § 1911(a).
  • A right of transfer to the Tribal Court, which shall be granted absent good cause shown and absent objection by either parent. 25 U.S.C. § 1911(b). Any non-tribal court presented with such a matter is requested to transfer it promptly to the Tribal Court.
  • Full faith and credit for any Tribal Court order, in every court of the United States. 25 U.S.C. § 1911(d) and § 1914.

VIII. Emergency Physical Safety — Narrow and Expressly Limited Exception

Nothing in this Notice prevents any person from taking immediate, good-faith action to protect a child from imminent physical harm. Any such action, however:

  • shall be limited to what is necessary to secure the child’s immediate physical safety;
  • shall be reported immediately to the Office of the Head Chief and to the Tribal Court;
  • shall be promptly reviewed by the Tribal Court, which has exclusive authority to determine placement and to apply the Welfare Principle; and
  • shall not be treated as conferring jurisdiction on any non-tribal court or agency, as creating any continuing authority outside the tribal government, or as a basis for the removal of the child from the guardian’s care beyond the emergency itself.

Emergency action to protect a child is not an exception to tribal jurisdiction. It is a temporary measure that tribal jurisdiction then resolves. Once the imminent danger has passed, § 1922 requires the child’s return or transfer to tribal jurisdiction.

IX. Reservation of Sovereign Rights; Non-Waiver

The publication of this Notice is not a waiver of any sovereign right of the National Federation of Mendocino. Specifically, and without limitation, the National Federation does not waive:

  • sovereign immunity;
  • exclusive or concurrent tribal jurisdiction;
  • the right to decline recognition of any non-tribal order, judgment, finding, or report;
  • the right to seek relief in any forum of competent jurisdiction to protect a tribal-nation child; or
  • the right to amend or supplement this Notice.

If any provision of this Notice is held invalid, the remaining provisions remain in full force.

X. Relationship to the Welfare Principle — Closing Statement

The Welfare Principle requires an individualized, evidence-based determination of a child’s best interests. It does not authorize any identity-based presumption for or against any person or community, and it does not authorize any forum to act without jurisdiction. In a tribal case concerning a tribal-nation child, the Welfare Principle is interpreted and applied by the tribal government, and by no other authority. A non-tribal court or agency that uses a “welfare” rationale to keep such a child from a safe guardian, without satisfying the federal standards set out in Section V, is acting without federal authority and contrary to the Indian Child Welfare Act.

XI. Attestation

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and caused the seal of the Office of the Head Chief to be affixed on this 18th day of November, 2026.

/SS//S/__
Lord Devin: Mallonee
Head Chief, National Federation of Mendocino

Certificate of Publication

This Public Notice is published on the official public notice forum of the National Federation of Mendocino on November 18, 2026.

Publication Date: November 18, 2026
Notice Reference: NFM-2026-PN-004
Act No.: NFM-2026-CCSAR-003

← All notices

Official Document — CCSAR Protection Act of 2026

The full text of the Act (Act No. NFM-2026-CCSAR-003) is displayed below. Open in a new tab →